Dialogue of 300,000 car disassembly research reports: If CITIC Securities wants to charge, you need to add some more dry goods

Zhongxin Jingwei, July 31 (Ma Jing intern Li Wenqian) The sequel to the dismantling car is here again. After being suspected of plagiarism by the Snowball user "01 corewell", CITIC Securities responded that CITIC Securities said that it was clearly marked on page 31 that the citations of the "01 core news" view were clearly marked. On the 30th, 01 Xinwen said to Zhongxin Jingwei that there was still objection to the response to CITIC Securities, and "(picture) reference was incorrect."

"No matter what is right," 01 Xinwen also said in an interview that he currently works in Silicon Valley in the United States and has studied the inverter for more than 15 years. , But it is also a characteristic, you can encourage securities company investment and research institutions to walk on the right path.

The research report of CITIC Securities Securities was questioned "plagiarism"

On July 18th, CITIC Securities TMT and the automobile team took two months to disassemble a Tesla Model 3 in collaboration with a number of companies and institutions. Teachers, 6 of them are chief analysts. After the research report was published, it immediately aroused widespread market attention.

Just 10 days later, on July 28, 01 Xinwen posted a disagreement on the research report of CITIC Securities' car demolition in Snowball. The 01 core news stated in the foreword that I also benefited a lot from this research report, but "the electric power assembly as one of the core components of the smart electric vehicle, especially the inverter, did not provide much in the report. Original content. 30-32 pages to Tesla's model Model S power assembly. Its content and picture are almost from the original article "Where's the Surging Power of Tesla"? It was reorganized and the pictures were split. The report not only did not give the reference source, but also copied the original error in the original text to the report. I hope that when CITIC Securities is cited next time, at least I find the author's school -to -school countermeasures. a bit."

The picture on the left is the 01 core Wenwen article, and the picture on the right is CITIC Securities Research Report.

In this regard, CITIC Securities responded to the media on the evening of July 29 that the research report clearly marked the reference to the "01 core news" view on page 31; Maguire, Turbo Electric, is consistent with the source of the picture labeled by the "01 core news" article.

CITIC Securities Research Report on page 31 mentioned a phrase "Disassembling according to 01 cores" Source: CITIC Securities Research Report

However, CITIC Securities did not give a corresponding response to the research report content pointed out.

"As soon as I woke up, I suddenly became angry. A fantasy drift of a self -media worker." 01 Xinwen said to Zhongxin Jingwei that CITIC Securities has been in contact with me, but because of sometimes exchanges with domestic exchanges, communication between the two parties, communication between the two parties, the communication between the two parties, the communication between the two parties, the communication between the two parties, the communication between the two parties, the communication between the two parties, and the communication between the two parties. Not unfolding yet.

Regarding the response of CITIC Securities, the 01 corewell said that the introduction of the LDU (line drive) comes from its original text, but did not provide relevant reference descriptions. In addition, the reference is inappropriate to split from the pictures of its articles. CITIC Securities should not only indicate the original source (DAMIEN MAGUIRE, TURBO ELECTRIC), but also needs to mention the 01 core news of specific data integration and analysis. After all Specific structure.

Related path of the dispute picture listed by the core news: 01 Core news about the picture

Lawyer: You need to be qualitative depending on the specific situation

How to look at the aforementioned situation from the legal level, Yang Huaquan, deputy chairman and secretary -general of the Beijing Intellectual Property Law Research Association, and associate professor of Beijing University of Technology, said in an interview with China New Jingwei that the articles published by netizens on the Internet are like publishing articles offline. If To meet the constituent elements of the work, it can also enjoy copyright and be protected. The article published on the Internet also needs to indicate the source, indicating the author's name and work name, otherwise there will be the risk of infringement of the right to signature and the right to copy the right to replicate, the right to issue (real space) or information network dissemination (network environment).

"Plagiarism or plagiarism is not a legal term. The right to violate the behavior needs to be dependent on the specific situation." Yang Huaquan also mentioned that there is another "mixed principle" in the copyright law, that is, only one or very limited expression of thought is only one or very limited expression. Then these expressions are regarded as the category of "thought" without being protected by copyright law. The description of the Tesla Model S dynamic assembly on page 30 of the dispute report is from the "Tesla surging power? "The description of this is similar, and it seems to meet the principle, so it is difficult to identify plagiarism or plagiarism.

Meng Bo, a lawyer of Beijing Jingshi Law Firm, did not analyze the above situation, but he told Zhongxin Jingwei that Article 24 of the Copyright Law stipulates the situation of thirteen "reasonable use", that is, in these thirteen situations Using the work below, you can pay for it without a copy of the copyright owner. "Reasonable use" does not belong to the violation of copyright.

Meng Bo mentioned that taking "appropriate reference" as an example, in judicial practice, the court usually considers whether the purpose of reference is to introduce, comment on a certain work or explain a certain question; Whether the proportion of space occupies is too high; whether the author's name or name, and the name of the work are specified; whether the copyright owner uses the normal use of his works; whether it is unreasonable to damage the legitimate rights and interests of the copyright owner to qualitatively qualitatively. "It is necessary to disassemble the research report, but it is difficult to do well."

It is worth noting that 01 Xinwen also published an article on the snowball on July 30th an article "How to Trimite the CITIC Securities" to further respond. From the content of the content, how to correct the errors in the research report of the car and make a proposal to make a professional research report occupy the main length of the article.

01 Xinwen told Zhongxin Jingwei that he worked in Silicon Valley in the United States and mainly studied inverters. The research time has exceeded 15 years. He also shared his views on how to evaluate the research report of CITIC Securities and whether the research report in the field of new energy vehicle research was desirable.

01 Xinwen's suggestions for research reports on securities firms: Disassembled one of the latest model Tesla Source: 01 Core Wen article

The 01 core news emphasized that although the content of CITIC Securities Research Report is omissions, it is only for the content of the electric power assembly (inverter, silicon carbide module) in it. If you want to evaluate properly, suitable for getting started, if it is free research report, there is no problem, but if you want to charge, the content needs to be added. "

01 Xinwen believes that the research report of car disassembly is very necessary, and professional field surveys are also very welcome, but this is also difficult to do well. "First of all, it is in terms of ideas. It was resolved by Haitong and CITIC. "

Not long ago, Haitong International dismantled a BYD, and CITIC Securities demolished a Tesla Model 3, which is a rare move for domestic securities research, but in fact, international investment banks have a precedent. Public information shows that UBS has taken the lead in creating an electric vehicle dismantling series since 2017. The UBS car research team dismantled Chevrolet's Bolt electric vehicle in 2017, and in 2018 dismantled Tesla's Model 3, in 2018, it disassembled the ID3 electric vehicle created by Volkswagen MEB pure electricity platform. Because of this, some netizens commented on CITIC Securities' dismantling Tesla Model 3, "Is it too late to disassemble now?"

"Actually, it is a good thing. At least the securities firms can make some valuable research reports, not like the water thesis before." 01 Xinwen said. In his opinion, after solving the problem of ideas, it is the technical problem. At present, the professionalism of the dismantling person has risen from the secondary contradiction to the main contradiction, and this is a problem at home and abroad.

"Now there are many segments in electric vehicles, and there are many corresponding segments in the corresponding segment. No one is all talents." 01 corewen believes that the method of solving this problem is best to be a manufacturer in the electric vehicle supply chain. The machine to achieve the effect of a stone number bird.

01 Xinwen also emphasized that from an international perspective, this research report of CITIC Securities is suitable for electric car popular science textbooks, suitable for training for new entrants, or to quickly learn to learn more senior engineers who are preparing to change the track. , But it is also a characteristic, you can encourage securities company investment and research institutions to walk on the right path.

"The real good broker should be 'positive harmony, with a strange victory', that is, the foundation must be solid, and can make accurate interpretation and analysis from the direction of technology and market. Market analysis, company analysis, etc.) to achieve the leadership status of a certain or some segmented field, "01 corewell said.

Regarding the latest post on the response to CITIC Securities, Zhongxin Jingwei contacted CITIC Securities to seek response, but there is no update response. (For more report clues, please contact the author Ma Jing: [email protected]) (Zhongxin Jingwei APP)

Copyright Copyright Copyright, without written authorization, no unit or individual may reprint, extract or use it in other ways.

Editor in charge: Wei Wei

Pay attention to the official WeChat public account of JWVIEW (JWVIEW) to get more elite financial information.

- END -